By 
A hard would you rather is one where both options cost you something, making it harder to answer in half a second. Read it out, have everyone pick a side, then ask one person to explain. Start here:
- Would you rather always know when someone’s lying to you or always be able to get away with lying yourself?
- Would you rather always know what to say or always know what to do?
If your group splits, ask each side to make its case. If everyone agrees instantly, try a harder one.
Every question here comes from Lolo Cards - 5,200+ conversation cards for iPhone.
What makes a question hard
Mental Floss, in its hard would-you-rather list, describes some pairs as “agonizingly difficult” and calls the questions a way to look at your own values and your friends’ values. The hard ones make you give up something you care about, like honesty for comfort, or a better past for a clearer future.
Quick test before you read one out: can you build a good argument for each side? If one side is obviously better, the round will be over fast. If you hesitate, the room probably will too.
Pick for the room as well. With old friends, you might try a question about trust. With a group that met an hour ago, start with “calm life to 100 or wild one to 60”. Start lighter, then go heavier as people loosen up.
Hard questions to open with
These are sorted from “needs a moment” to “needs a minute”. Ask them one at a time and give people a few seconds to think.
- Would you rather be able to change one decision from your past or know one thing about your future?
- Would you rather live a calm life to 100 or a wild one to 60?
- Would you rather never be able to lie or never be able to keep a secret?
- Would you rather live in a world where everyone is brutally honest or where everyone is politely dishonest?
- Would you rather lose all your memories or never make new ones again?
Let people defend their pick
After everyone picks, ask one person on each side: “Why that one?” Then ask someone on the other side to say, in their own words, what the first person just said, before they answer back.
This also slows the game down, which suits heavy questions. Julia Minson, a decision scientist at Harvard Kennedy School, says one reason disagreement is hard is that we assume our own view is the right and real one. She treats listening as central: letting the person you’re talking with feel heard. A separate set of experiments by Guy Itzchakov at the University of Haifa, written up in Psyche, found that when a listener paid close attention, speakers felt more connected and their attitudes became less extreme. The listeners weren’t trying to persuade anyone.
Those studies were about serious disagreements, not party games, so we won’t claim your living room works the same way. You can still use this as a house rule for a debate round: nobody argues back until they’ve repeated the other side’s reasoning.
Some rules that keep a heated round friendly:
- Everyone gets their turn to explain before anyone gets a second turn.
- You can change your mind out loud, and nobody teases you for it.
- “I don’t know” is allowed once per person.
- The reader answers last so they don’t steer the room.
Questions that push harder
Once people are comfortable, try these. They touch on trust, loneliness and apologies, so read the group first. If you see someone go quiet, pick a lighter one next.
- Would you rather lose your trust in people or in yourself?
- Would you rather always be the one who apologizes first or never apologize again?
- Would you rather live without ever feeling lonely again or without ever feeling anxious again?
- Would you rather go a year without the internet or a year without your closest friends?
- Would you rather have a rewind button or a pause button for your life?
You’ll find more hard picks, plus funny, crazy and food rounds, on the would you rather questions page. If your group wants a lighter warm-up first, try our funny would you rather round.
When to move on
Not every question needs a ten-minute debate. Move on when:
- The same person has been talking for a few minutes and others are checking their phones.
- The answers have turned into a fight about something outside the game.
- Someone says “can we do a different one?” Say yes right away. Nobody has to explain.
- The room lands on a clear split and everyone has had their say.
End on a light one so the evening doesn’t stay stuck on the heavy question. A quick “fly or be invisible” works fine, and you can read it out in your best announcer voice.
